MTG Card Grading Guide: Is It Worth Grading Your Magic Cards?

Learn when grading Magic cards makes financial sense, the differences between grading services, and what grades your Alpha and Beta cards need.

Grading Magic cards requires different considerations than Pokemon. With BGS competing strongly with PSA and Alpha/Beta cards being notoriously condition-sensitive, here's what you need to know.

BGS vs PSA for Magic

Unlike Pokemon where PSA dominates, Magic collectors are split between services:

• BGS (Beckett): Preferred by many MTG collectors, offers sub-grades, 10 = "Pristine" or "Black Label"
• PSA: Growing in MTG popularity, higher liquidity on eBay, single grade
• CGC: Newer option gaining traction, competitive pricing

Alpha and Beta Card Challenges

The oldest Magic cards present unique grading challenges:

• Print Quality: Alpha/Beta had inconsistent print quality from the factory
• Centering: Often severely off-center, limiting grade potential
• Corner Cuts: Hand-cut sheets led to irregular corners
• Surface Issues: Ink spots, roller marks, and print lines common

"A BGS 9 Alpha card is exceptional. Don't expect PSA 10s from 1993 print runs."

When to Grade MTG Cards

Consider grading when:

1. Reserved List cards: Scarcity justifies grading cost
2. Alpha/Beta/Unlimited: Vintage premium makes grading worthwhile
3. High-value foils: Pack-fresh foils with grade potential
4. Long-term holds: Cards you plan to keep 5+ years

Cards NOT Worth Grading

Skip grading for:

• Modern reprints of non-Reserved List cards
• Bulk rares regardless of condition
• Cards with visible wear (unless Alpha/Beta)
• Anything you plan to play with

Preparing MTG Cards for Grading

MTG-specific preparation tips:

• Check foiling for scratches under bright light
• Examine white borders carefully for edge wear
• Use perfect fit inner sleeves for foils (prevent shifting)
• Be honest about grade potential—BGS 9.5 is tough

• All guides
• Card prices
• Card prices
• Set lists
• Pokémon collection
• Pricing
• FAQ
• About